Moncton metropolis corridor prompts criticism after cancelling annual menorah show Specific Instances

Article content material

Moncton, N.B., has ignited a firestorm of criticism for cancelling its annual menorah show, with no less than one outstanding critic suggesting the choice is said to tensions over the Israel-Hamas conflict.

Francis Weil, president of the Moncton Jewish Group, stated Mayor Daybreak Arnold gave Jewish leaders the information this week, blaming a 2015 Supreme Courtroom of Canada ruling that council conferences shouldn’t open with prayer.

Article content material

Weil instructed the Nationwide Submit on Saturday the argument made is unnecessary, noting Christmas symbols stay on metropolis corridor grounds, which he helps. The menorah had been a 20-year custom at metropolis corridor.

“We’re not speaking about prayer. Within the place the place the menorah goes, there are a pair Christmas bushes and some angels,” he stated.

Arnold and town’s media spokespeople didn’t instantly reply to a request for remark from the Submit on Saturday. The CBC reported they didn’t reply to earlier requests from the nationwide broadcaster.

It comes at a time of rising antisemitism and anti-Israel demonstrations throughout Canada from pro-Palestinian supporters, together with weekly demonstrations at Moncton metropolis corridor that Weil stated have included pro-Hamas indicators and slogans.

“That’s the very first thing I instructed her, this isn’t the time to make this choice, as a result of everybody will suppose you’re giving in,” Weil stated, including the mayor by no means acknowledged any connection to tensions, however did allude to desirous to keep away from hassle.

Article content material

“On the time, she type of stated if there’s an incident at metropolis corridor, it might make headlines all around the nation. However she didn’t say what incident.”

The choice was pilloried Saturday by nationwide Jewish leaders and others.

“If some religion symbols are OK, however others are usually not, that’s discrimination. It’s not acceptable and should be instantly corrected,” the Centre for Israel and Jewish Affairs stated Saturday on X, the platform previously generally known as Twitter.

Michael Levitt, president and CEO of the Mates of Simon Wiesenthal Heart, stated the choice “reeks of discrimination” in a Saturday publish on X.

“This inexplicable choice, made beneath the guise of separation of church and state, is being bemoaned by the native Jewish group and should not stand,” Levitt stated.

“There are lots of people upset,” Dominic Cardy, a New Brunswick MLA and interim chief of the fledgling Canadian Future Occasion federally, stated on Twitter. “That is already tarnishing our picture throughout the nation. Don’t give in to thugs. Please reverse this horrible choice.”

Cardy shared a publish from outstanding Moncton lawyer Mike Murphy connecting the transfer to the present battle within the Mideast, which began on Oct. 7 when Hamas terrorists launched an assault on Israel, killing no less than 1,200 Israelis, together with infants and youngsters, and raped and kidnaped ladies.

Article content material

“There are a whole lot of weak individuals on the market. Workforce Hamas has gained a spherical in Moncton with the Menorah being stored in storage. Our household lived side-by-side with the Jewish group right here within the East Finish. I went to highschool with many from there. Disgrace!” stated Murphy, a former New Brunswick justice minister.

Weil stated that he might be writing all 10 metropolis councillors asking them to reverse the choice, including that Hanukkah begins Wednesday and there’s nonetheless time.

“The mayor is an efficient individual, I like her very a lot. However the best way she is considering simply doesn’t make any sense,” he stated.

Our web site is the place for the newest breaking information, unique scoops, longreads and provocative commentary. Please bookmark nationalpost.com and join our newsletters right here.

Share this text in your social community